Google Search Versus Academic Library Search

February 21, 2017

Well, Dartmouth’s library search does a killer job on topics like employee compensation, regression analysis, and the intricacies of duacetylmorphine. Google does a better job with Lady Gaga, where to buy pizza in Toledo, and learning about Google services.

I know this because I read and believed “Google Search engine vs Dartmouth Library Search.” The write up is a clarion call to the way things were. I can hear echoes of free Dialog training, the blandishments of the LexisNexis and Westlaw sales professionals, and the explanations of silver, gold, titanium, platinum, and diamond versions of Ebsco’s databases.

The write up points out:

Dartmouth Library access to thousands of articles, journals, abstracts, papers and theses from Dartmouth College, the other Ivy leagues, the other top universities, even out of the United States. So, to answer to the question, what is the difference between Google and Dartmouth Library, I would say Google is more public and is open to everybody. But, it doesn’t give us all of the actual research papers and publications.

Lousy writing aside, research libraries offer more reliable and slightly less crazed information than one finds in the Google index.

What’s frightening me is that this type of comparison is necessary.

Stephen E Arnold, February 21, 2017

Comments

Comments are closed.

  • Archives

  • Recent Posts

  • Meta