Another Example of the Corrosive Function of Digital Information
February 18, 2022
“In Praise of Search Tools” contains an interesting statement. Here it is:
the shaping-up of the book that Duncan describes as he charts the advent of modern search tools might also be seen as a pulling-apart of the book. The alphabetical table that is the index “breaks down a book into its constituents.” Its structure is entirely independent from the structure of the work, sacrificing the latter for the reader’s better convenience. The alphabetical order used by the indexer breaks texts up into so many word-sized bits, but the dismemberment at issue in the culture of indexing was sometimes literal, as when concordance-makers took scissors to the pages whose words they were regrouping. In a 1919 article on the making of a concordance to the poetry of William Wordsworth, a Cornell professor describes how the eight volumes of the Oxford edition were transmuted by his team into 210,944 paper slips: records of each appearance of each of the poet’s keywords.
Interesting and in line with my ASIS Eagleton Lecture given in the mid 1980s.
Stephen E Arnold, February 18, 2022
Comments
-
- Subscribe to Beyond Search
Feature archive
News archive
-
