Why Search When You Can Discover
November 11, 2016
What’s next in search? My answer is, “No search at all. The system thinks for you.” Sounds like Utopia for the intellectual couch potato to me.
I read “The Latest in Search: New Services in the Content Discovery Marketplace.” The main point of the write up is to highlight three “discovery” services. A discovery service is one which offers “information users new avenues to the research literature.”
See, no search needed.
The three services highlighted are:
- Yewno, which is powered by an inference engine. (Does anyone remember the Inference search engine from days gone by?). The Yewno system uses “computational analysis and a concept map.” The problem is that it “supplements institutional discovery.” I don’t know what “institutional discovery” means, and my hunch is that folks living outside of rural Kentucky know what “institutional discovery” means. Sorry to be so ignorant.
- ScienceOpen, which delivers a service which “complements open Web discovery.” Okay. I assume that this means I run an old fashioned query and ScienceOpen helps me out.
- TrendMD, which “serves as a classic “onward journey tool” that aims to generate relevant recommendations serendipitously.”
I am okay with the notion of having tools to make it easier to locate information germane to a specific query. I am definitely happy with tools which can illustrate connections via concept maps, link analysis, and similar outputs. I understand that lawyers want to type in a phrase like “Panama deal” and get a set of documents related to this term so the mass of data can be chopped down by sending, recipient, time, etc.
But setting up discovery as a separate operation from keyword or entity based search seems a bit forced to me. The write up spins its lawn mower blades over the TrendMD service. That’s fine, but there are a number of ways to explore scientific, technical, and medical literature. Some are or were delightful like Grateful Med; others are less well known; for example, Mednar and Quertle.
Discovery means one thing to lawyers. It means another thing to me: A search add on.
Stephen E Arnold, November 11, 2016
Comments
2 Responses to “Why Search When You Can Discover”
-
- Subscribe to Beyond Search
Feature archive
News archive
-
You need to do some research on ‘institutional’ discovery services, as they are used throughout most libraries, academic and public. They have become critical in uncovering all of the diverse resources a library has, and companies have organized around this offering.
I’d like your informed opinion on discovery services, after you have done your homework.
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC4816486/ Here’s a study on the three main services.