Visualization: Interesting and Mostly Misleading
May 7, 2009
i fund the EVvie award for excellence in search system analysis. This year’s number two winner was Martin Baumgartel for his paper “Advanced Visualization of Search Results: More Risks, or More Chances?”. You can read the full text here and a brief interview with him here. You will want to read Mr. Baumgartel’s paper and then the Fast Company article called “Is Information Visualization the Next Frontier for Design?” here by Michael Cannell.
These two write ups point out the difference between a researcher’s approach to the role of visualization and a journalist’s approach to the subject. In a nutshell, visualization works in certain situations. In most information retrieval applications, visualization is not a benefit.
The Fast Company approach hits on the eye candy value of visualization. The title wisely references design. Visualization as illustration can enhance a page of text. Visualization as an aid to information analysis may not deliver the value desired.
Which side of the fence is right for your search system? Selective use of visualization or eye candy? The addled goose favors selectivity. Most visualizations of data distract me, but your response may be different. Functionality, not arts and crafts, appeal to the addled goose.
Stephen Arnold, May 7, 2009
Comments
-
- Subscribe to Beyond Search
Feature archive
News archive
-
