Ah, Apple, Struggling with AI like Amazon, Google, et al
March 14, 2025
This blog post is the work of a humanoid dino baby. If you don’t know what a dinobaby is, you are not missing anything. Ask any 80 year old why don’t you?
Yes, it is Friday, March 14, 2025. Everyone needs a moment of amusement. I found this luscious apple bit and thought I would share it. Dinobabies like knowing how the world and Apple treats other dinobabies. You, as a younger humanoid, probably don’t care. Someday you will.
“Grandmother Gets X-Rated Message after Apple AI Fail” reports:
A woman from Dunfermline has spoken of her shock after an Apple voice-to-text service mistakenly inserted a reference to sex – and an apparent insult – into a message left by a garage… An artificial intelligence (AI) powered service offered by Apple turned it into a text message which – to her surprise – asked if she been "able to have sex" before calling her a "piece of ****".
Not surprisingly, Apple did not respond to the BBC request for a comment. Unperturbed, the Beeb made some phone calls. According to the article:
An expert has told the BBC the AI system may have struggled in part because of the caller’s Scottish accent, but far more likely factors were the background noise at the garage and the fact he was reading off a script.
One BBC expert offered these reasons for the foul fouled message:
Peter Bell, a professor of speech technology at the University of Edinburgh, listened to the message left for Mrs Littlejohn. He suggested it was at the "challenging end for speech-to-text engines to deal with". He believes there are a number of factors which could have resulted in rogue transcription:
- The fact it is over the telephone and, therefore, harder to hear
- There is some background noise in the call
- The way the garage worker speaks is like he is reading a prepared script rather than speaking in a natural way
"All of those factors contribute to the system doing badly, " he added. "The bigger question is why it outputs that kind of content.
I have a much simpler explanation. Like Microsoft, marketing is much easier than delivering something that works for humans. I am tempted to make fun of Apple Intelligence, conveniently abbreviated AI. I am tempted to point out that real world differences in the flow of Apple computers are not discernable when browsing Web pages or entering one’s iTunes password into the system several times a day.
Let’s be honest. Apple is big. Like Amazon (heaven help Alexa by the way), Google (the cheese fails are knee slappers, Sundar), and the kindergarten squabbling among Softies and OpenAI at Microsoft — Apple cannot “do” smart software at this time. Therefore, errors will occur.
On the other hand, perhaps the dinobaby who received the message is “a piece of ****"? Most dinobabies are.
Stephen E Arnold, March 14, 2025
Comments
Got something to say?
-
- Subscribe to Beyond Search
Feature archive
News archive
-
